AP Notes, Outlines, Study Guides, Vocabulary, Practice Exams and more!

Chapter 21 - Urban America and the Progressive Era

Chpter21.doc41 KB
The Currents of Progressivism
- Progressives could be found in all classes, regions, and races
- Felt that America needed a new social consciousness to cope with problems
- Several key issues behind progressivism:
- Ending political corruption
- More businesslike governing methods
- More compassionate leglislative response to the excesses of industrialism
- Many feel this term is exceedingly vague
Unifying Themes
- Three basic attitudes behind progressive movements:
- Anger over the excesses of industrial capitalism and urban growth
- Emphasized social cohesion and common bonds to understand modern society
- Against social Darwinism
- Felt citizens needed to intervene to improve social conditions
- Progressives offered a combination of social justice and social control
Women Spearhead Reform
- Many middle class women supported the settlement house movement
- Reformers such as Jane Addams and Florence Kelley promoted female education
The Urban Machine
- Women had to work outside existing political institutions
- City politics had become a closed and corrupt system
- Machine politics - well organised, dominant political parties catering to specific voters
- Viewed their work as a business, served people who needed assistance
- “Honest Graft” - Making money from inside information on public improvements
- Timothy “Big Tim” Sullivan - embodied the machine politics style
- Gained votes by helping pass reforming legislature, eg. child labour laws, etc
Political Progressives and Urban Reform
- Political progressivism originated in the cities to challenge machine politics
- Governments hardly seemed capable of providing basic essential services
- “Good Government Movement” - led by the National Municipal League
- Fought to make city management a non-partisan process, like a large corporation
- Progressive politicans focused on changing policies, not the political structure
Progressive in the Statehouse
- “Wisconsin Idea” - The application of academic scholarship and theory to public needs
- Adopted by many states
- Western progressives displayed the greatest enthusiasm for institutional political reform
- The Initiative - allowed direct vote on an issue raised by petition
- The Referendum - allowed voters to decide on bills referred to them by the legislature
- These and other measures intentionally weakened political parties
- Southern populism = biracial policies         - Southern progressivism = whites only
- Southern progressives supported black disfranchisement as a reform
- “Grandfather clauses” - uneducated whites could vote if their grandfather was able to
- Southern progressives pushed for fully segregated public areas
New Journalism: Muckraking
- Jacob Riis - How the Other Half Lives - first real exposé detailing poor living conditions
- Journals such as McClure’s began uncovering the bad side of American life
- Journalists included Lincoln Steffen (The Shame of the Cities) and Ida Tarbell (History of the Standard Oil Company)
- Exposure Journalism, as it was called, paid handsomely
- President Theodore Roosevelt coined the term “muckrakers” for these journalists
Intellectual Trends Promoting Reform
- Intellectual thinkers began challenging several core American ideas - this led to reforms
- L. F. Ward - Dynamic Sociology - said applying Soc. Darwinism to society was wrong
- Legal, educational and industrial reformers began speaking out against their fields
- Lochner v. New York - Judge Holmes ruled that a 10-hour day for bankers was wrong
- Holmes affected a new group of lawyers known as the “social jurisprudence”
- Edward A. Ross - Social Control - became a key phrase in progressive thought
- Argued that society needed an elite with the best interests of society at heart
Social Control and Its Limits
- Some progressives felt they were acting for the common good, but were actually racists
- Extreme side of these views supported eugenics (making a supreme race)
The Prohibition Movement
- WCTU provided women with their first political forum to voice their protests
- Core supporteres were generally small-town, Protestant, native-born Americans
- Some “ritualists” protested against prohibition - usually working-class immigrants
The Social Evil
- New movements arose to reform society in general - prostitution, gambling, etc
- Portrayed religious minorities as the cause of these vices
- Huge crackdowns in prostitution districts only led to the transformation of the sex trade
The Redemption of Leisure
- Progressives felt that “commercialised leisure” must be closely watched
- 1909 - NYC movie producers joined to make the National Board of Censorship (NBC)
- 1914 - The NBC reviewed 95% of the nation’s film output
Standardizing Education
- Public schools were seen primarily as agents of “Americanization” - huge melting pot
- 1930 - 47% of kids aged 14-17 were in school
- Progressives led the way in developing specialized fields of study
Working-Class Communities and Protest
- Industrial Rev reached its peak in the early 19th century
- Differences between workers in skill, ethnicity and race proved to be powerful barriers
- Industrial workers began calling for increased social justice
The New Immigrants
- Untrained foreign immigrants became the bottom rank of the American workforce
- Certain industries became dominated by particular ethnicities
- Most immigrants came from Europe, although some came from Asia
- Barrios - Southern communities dominated by Mexican immigrants
Urban Ghettos
- Immigrants moved to ghettos filled with their countrymen, densely packed poor areas
- NYC became the center of the garment trade, which employed many Jews
- Huge work force united as one to strike against the garment manufacturers
- Known as the Uprising of the 20,000
- March 25th, 1911 - huge fire in the Triangle Shirtwaist Company
- Workers couldn’t escape due to the locked doors, many jumped to their deaths
Company Towns
- Many workers lived in company towns (Hershey, PA, etc) but had no influence there
- Immigrants had higher death rates because they did not understand safety instructions
- Women added to the family income by taking boarders, sewing, doing laundry, etc
- Women struggled with longer hours than the men and the latters’ excessive drinking
- Companies hired “efficency experts” to make sure the workers did as much as possible
- Strikers were met with opposition from the companies as well as the “neutral” army
- In 1913-14, the Colorado coal workers went on a major strike
- State sent in National Guard, who proceeded to side with the company
The AFL: “Unions, Pure and Simple”
- After the 1890’s, the American Federation of Labor emerged as the strongest union
- Unions’ strength gave rise to descrimination from whites against other workers
- Although members of one union, the various industries disliked each other
- National Association of Manufacturers launched a campaign to eradicate unions 
- Only in the 1930’s could unions count on legal support
The IWW: “One Big Union”
- Tensions grew between unions and the employers; many strikes turned violent
- Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) formed in Chicago to facilitate the “workers struggle to unite as a class, take possession of the earth, and abolish the wage system”
- Briefly became a force against the AFL
- Some violent union demonstrations ended up hindering the IWW’s progress
- McNamara brothers bombing the Los Angeles Times’ offices
Rebels in Bohemia
- Reformers gathered in NYC’s Greenwich Village
- Sympathized with labour struggles, liked modern art, were open to socialism
- “Village bohemians”, especially women, challenged social double standards
- Pre-hippie Hippies
- “Bohemian” - anyone who had artistic / intellectual dreams and disregarded social rules
- Bohemian views displayed in the monthly socialist magazine The Masses
- Bohemians organised a reproduction of a NJ silk workers strike displayed at MSG 
- Viewed as an artistic triumph
- Village bohemia lasted a few years, but Greenwich Village is still a gathering place for artsy types looking for experimentation
Women’s Movements and Black Awakening
- New women’s associations gave women a place in public life and more civil influence
- Black progressives fought to preserve rights they had gained during Reconstruction
The New Woman
- 1900 - 7% of Americans went to high schoool - 60% of these were women
- 1890 - General Fed. of Women’s Clubs brought together 200 local clubs of women
- Club activity led members to participate in other reform ventures
- Included “child-saving” reforms, eg. child labour laws, mother’s pensions, etc
- Women’s reform movements introduced quality control
Birth Control
- Margaret Sanger
- Coined the phrase “birth control” in 1913
- Threw herself into the bohemian society and became an organizer for the IWW
- Began her own magazine, the Woman Rebel
- After persecution for her views, she fled to Europe in Oct. 1914
- After Sanger was jailed, she gained lots of publicity for her crusade
Racism and Accomodation
- 1900 - 4/5ths of the US’s 10 million blacks still lived in the South
- Most worked in agriculture
- Some whites believed that blacks were genetically predisposed to the evils of society
- Used evolutionary theory to argue blacks could not improve = racial Darwinism
- Thomas Dixon - The Clansman - described the typical black as half man, half animal
Booker T. Washington
- The most influential black leader of his time
- Born a slave in 1856, educated at Hampton Institute
- 1881 - Founded Tuskegee Institute, a black school in Alabama
- Accomodationist philosophy - blacks and whites can work together for mutual benefit while remaining distinct from each other
- Up from Slavery - Washington’s widely-read biography
- Founded the National Negro Business League with Andrew Carnegie to help develop black business in black communities
- Consulted by Presidents Theodore Roosevelt and William Howard Taft on some issues
Racial Justice and the NAACP
- W.E.B. Du Bois offered an alternative to Washington’s leadership
- Did not fully accept the values of the dominant white society
- Du Bois criticized Washington for accepting the “alleged inferiority of the Negro”
- Niagara movement - protested the denial of black rights and other descrimination
- Held at Niagara Falls, Canada
- Failed to generate much change
- National Association for the Advancement of Coloured People - NAACP
- Led struggles to overturn legal and economic barriers to equal opportunity
National Progressivism
- Both Theodore Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson called themselves “progressives”
- National level progressivism animated many perspectives
Theodore Roosevelt and Presidential Activism
- 1901 - Theodore Roosevelt became the youngest president in US History
- Roosevelt won national fame during the Spanish-American war
- Follows the pattern of war heros being elected to office
- Roosevelt felt that administrative agencies run by experts could satisfy everyone
Trustbusting and Regulation
- Roosevelt began breaking up monopolies under the Sherman Antitrust Act
- Included the Northern Securities Co, a railroad merger under J.P. Morgan
- Also included Standard Oil, owned by John D. Rockefeller 
- During Roosevelt’s two terms, the government filed 43 cases under the Sherman Act
- After Roosevelt was re-elected, he felt more comfortable pushing for regulations
- Pure Food and Drug Act - established the Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
- Tested drugs before they went on the market
- Journalism exposés warned consumers about false meat products, etc
- Some big businesses supported reforms because they drove small companies bankrupt
Conservation, Preservation, and the Environment
- Roosevelt worried about the environment, and created the U.S. Forest Service in 1905
- Headed by Gifford Pinchot, a conservationist
- Pinchot believed in the “wise use” of America’s resources by the govt
- Some radicals such as John Muir wanted much more land preserved
- Many disagreements between conservationists and preservationists
- 1916 - National Park Service created - gave preservationists a voice in Washington
- Newlands Act - established a new federal presence in managing water resources
Republican Split
- 1908 - Roosevelt kept his promise to retire after a second term
- Named Taft as his successor, who easily defeated William Jennings Bryan
- During Taft’s presidency, the gap between Republicans widened
- Taft’s indecisive nature alienated Roosevelt and many other progressives
- When the old guard Republicans would not nominate Roosevelt in 1912, he and his supporters formed the Progressive Party, where he ran along with Hiram Johnson
The Election of 1912: A Four-Way Race
- The Democrats took advantage of the divisions among Republicans 
- Nominated Woodrow Wilson, who had the support of many of the party’s progressives
- Wilson contrasted his New Freedom campaign with Roosevelt’s New Nationalism
- 4th candidate was Eugene V. Debs, a Socialist
- Due to the Republican split, Wilson easily won, with an incredible 435 electoral votes
- Considered the first “modern election”
- Direct Primaries (switching parties)
- Challenging traditional party loyalties
- Issue-oriented campaigns
- A high degree of interest group activity
Woodrow Wilson’s First Term
- Wilson pushed for a greater federal role in regulating business and the economy
- By 1916, Wilson’s reform program looked more like New Nationalism
- 1913 - Underwood-Simmons Act reduced certain tariffs
- Took advantage of new 16th Amendment by imposing the first graduated federal income tax - up to 6%
- By creating federal reserve banks, the power of private banks was weakened
- Clayton Antitrust Act (1914) - replaced the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890
- Exempted unions as illegal combinations
- Federal Trade Commission (FTC) - Gave govt regulation control over corporations
Subject X2: 

Need Help?

We hope your visit has been a productive one. If you're having any problems, or would like to give some feedback, we'd love to hear from you.

For general help, questions, and suggestions, try our dedicated support forums.

If you need to contact the Course-Notes.Org web experience team, please use our contact form.

Need Notes?

While we strive to provide the most comprehensive notes for as many high school textbooks as possible, there are certainly going to be some that we miss. Drop us a note and let us know which textbooks you need. Be sure to include which edition of the textbook you are using! If we see enough demand, we'll do whatever we can to get those notes up on the site for you!